February 20, 2026 Orsolya Enyedi

Colic Calm vs Colic Calm Plus: What’s the Difference?

This article is intended for general information only and does not replace professional medical advice.

Quick Answer

Colic Calm and Colic Calm Plus are liquid dietary supplements suitable from 2 weeks of age and formulated to support digestive comfort in babies.

Colic Calm contains 8 botanical ingredients (including activated charcoal).
Colic Calm Plus contains 11 botanical ingredients (including activated charcoal) plus magnesium.

Some parents consider Colic Calm Plus if their baby appears particularly unsettled with wind, seems more gassy than usual, or is difficult to burp.

If you are unsure which option may be appropriate for your baby, consult your healthcare professional.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	🟡 Colic Calm	🔵 Colic Calm +
Suitable from	2 weeks old	2 weeks old
Total botanical ingredients	8	11
Activated charcoal	Yes	Yes
Magnesium	No	Yes
Essential oils	None	None
Simethicone	None	None
Alcohol	None	None
Sugar	None	None
Sodium bicarbonate	None	None
Wheat & gluten	None	None
Soy	None	None
Dairy	None	None
Animal-derived ingredients	None	None

Understanding Colic

Colic is a term used when a baby cries for extended periods without an obvious cause, while otherwise appearing healthy and feeding normally.

It is common in early infancy and often improves naturally by around 3 to 4 months of age.

Although it can be distressing for families, colic does not usually indicate illness.

Wind, Burping and Feeding Comfort

Some babies appear more sensitive to wind than others.

General parent guidance includes:

Burping during and after feeds
Holding baby upright after feeding
Gentle tummy time while awake

If your baby shows signs such as poor feeding, fever, lethargy, dehydration, persistent vomiting, or ongoing symptoms that may suggest reflux or another condition, seek clinical advice promptly.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between Colic Calm and Colic Calm Plus?

Colic Calm contains 8 botanical ingredients.
Colic Calm Plus contains 11 botanical ingredients and includes magnesium.

Do both products contain activated charcoal?

Yes. Both Colic Calm and Colic Calm Plus contain activated charcoal as part of their botanical ingredient blend.

When might parents consider Colic Calm Plus?

Some families prefer Colic Calm Plus because it contains additional botanical ingredients and magnesium. Product choice is personal and may depend on individual preference or professional advice.

Is the dosage the same for Colic Calm and Colic Calm Plus?

Yes. The recommended dosage is the same for both products. Always follow the directions on the label and consult your healthcare professional if you are unsure.

Are both products suitable from birth?

Both products are suitable from 2 weeks of age. Always follow label directions and consult your healthcare professional if you are unsure.

How do I know if my baby’s crying is colic?

Colic typically involves prolonged crying in an otherwise healthy baby. If your baby has additional symptoms such as fever, poor feeding, persistent vomiting, lethargy, or signs of reflux, seek clinical advice.

Can colic improve on its own?

Yes. Colic is common in early infancy and often improves naturally by around 3–4 months of age. If symptoms persist or you are concerned, consult your healthcare professional.

Can I change from Colic Calm to Colic Calm Plus?

If you are considering changing products, speak with your healthcare professional to ensure the option remains suitable for your baby.

Always read the label and use as directed. Dietary supplements are not a replacement for a balanced diet. If symptoms persist, see your healthcare professional. Colic Calm NZ, New Zealand.

Sources

The following sources are provided for general information and education only.

NHS — Colic
https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/colic/

Plunket — Colic
https://www.plunket.org.nz/child-health-concerns-and-symptoms/crying/colic/

Healthify NZ — Infant colic
https://healthify.nz/health-a-z/i/infant-colic

Healthify NZ — Reflux in infants
https://healthify.nz/health-a-z/r/reflux-infant-child

Raising Children (AU) — Wind & burping
https://raisingchildren.net.au/newborns/health-daily-care/health-concerns/wind

Colic Calm NZ — Product information
https://shop.coliccalm.co.nz/products/colic-calm-herbal-blend-59ml-supports-digestive-comfort-in-babies

https://shop.coliccalm.co.nz/products/colic-calm-plus-1

https://www.coliccalm.co.nz/

Filed in: baby colic, Baby Fussiness, colic infant, colicky baby, infant reflux, spit-up

Next article Vitamin D for Babies in Summer

93%

(100)

(6)

(1)

(0)

Helped my baby SO much!

My baby girl had been struggling with discomfort and was always arching her back and grizzling in a way I knew wasn’t just “normal” so I tried the probiotic vit D product out and it has helped her significantly!!! So glad I gave it a chance :)

Thank you so much for sharing this
We’re really glad you decided to try the Baby Probiotic + Vitamin D3 and that it’s been a good fit for your little one’s routine. It means a lot that you took the time to leave such lovely feedback.

Great support for newborn

I ordered this for my three week old formula fed baby girl who was experiencing gas, discomfort and fussiness. Definitely have seen an improvement over the past week of use helping with burping, tummy discomfort and passing of bowels. Highly recommend as the ingredients are lovely and supportive for all bubs

Those early newborn weeks can feel overwhelming, so we’re really glad the Colic Calm Plus & Infant Probiotic with Vitamin D Bundle has fitted well into your little one’s routine. We truly appreciate you taking the time to share such a thoughtful recommendation

Great product

It does wonders for our baby, and it’s so easy to use as it can be used anytime rather than being constrained by a feed time.

Thank you so much for sharing this We’re really glad to hear it’s been easy to use and fits smoothly into your baby’s routine.
It means a lot to us that you took the time to leave a review!

Instant relief

Have used this product for a week now and instantly saw a difference with gas, my baby seems happier after feedings. Would definitely buy again

Thank you so much for sharing your experience with our Baby Probiotic + Vitamin D3
We’re glad to hear it’s been easy to use and fits well into your baby’s daily routine.

Didn't work

Tried for a week but it seemed to only make her tummy more sore? Maybe just doesnt agree with my LO.

We’re genuinely sorry to hear this and appreciate you taking the time to let us know.

Every baby is different, and we know how difficult it can be when things don’t go as hoped. If you’d like to reach out, we’re always available via chat or email.

Wishing you and your little one all the very best

1 2 3

Colic Calm vs Colic Calm Plus: What’s the Difference?